Gayblack Canadian Man

Foreign Policy Analysis
Armenian Genocide – Erdogan Responds Armenian Minister (Eng. Subs) Armenia Lies on Armenian Genocide

Armenian Genocide – Erdogan Responds Armenian Minister (Eng. Subs) Armenia Lies on Armenian Genocide


You use the expression: “Massacred Christians, Massacred Armenians.” What is the basis for such statement? It is very dirty approach! What evidence do you have to support such conclusion? Right now the Armenian’s Minister of Foreign Affairs is among us. Look, I issued my invitation. I wrote a letter in 2005. I can repeat again. We have released our archives And to date over a million documents regarding the issue have been catalogued. If there is any evidence in Armenian archives, let them release them too. Let’s catalogue them as well. We suggest to commission archaeologist, historians, political scientists and lawyers to investigate and study the issue. If there are related archive data in any third countries, let’s look at them too. And only after that us, politicians, should agree the conclusion. But without such documental basis, Just denounce Turkey by repeating “In 1915 such genocide was committed” Is never honourable state of affairs. Our society and our culture has never embraced anything even resembling the concept of “genocide”. And it is not possible for us to accept that. We are ready for discussion on this topic at any point of time on the basis of facts and documents. And we invite Armenia to prepare itself in a similar fashion. But it is not possible to force us to accept allegations of genocide by behind the scenes lobbying effort in the parliaments of various countries. They can keep labelling us in this manner as much as they want. We shall never agree with that There is no such thing! But let them produce their proofs. After that , if necessary, we will account for our history. And I am saying that clearly and openly! With respect to Mr. Oskanyan’s question regarding diplomatic issues between our countries. Look Mr. Oskanyan, when I became Prime Minister, You know there was no air traffic between Armenia and Turkey. I took office and opened that air traffic exchange corridor. And now, there are regular scheduled cargo fights between Armenia and Istanbul. Second. To send the message of good will, There is Lake Van on the east of my country. There is island of Akdamar on that lake. On that island there is Armenian, Related to Armenian citizens of our country, Christian Orthodox Church. This Church collapsed. We have restored and renovated this Church. And opened it’s doors to our Armenian citizens, As well as to tourists coming from abroad. We wanted this to be message of good will. There are over 40 thousands of Armenians living in Turkey, Who came here from abroad. Why those Armenians fleeing to my country? In any event, there are no any issues between us and our Armenian citizens. Our relations are perfect. But now in addition to them, 40 thousands more Armenians came to my country. Ok – why did they come ? You should all ask yourselves – why ? Of all the places in the world including Armenian itself, why did they prefer come to Turkey? Because Turkey is a country of piece. That is why they are coming. I also want to emphasise that. On the issue of Nagorno Karabakh, You know the issue delayed because of Minsk group still cannot resolve this. But the world accepted Armenia as an aggressor in Nagorno Karabakh. Leave Karabakh! Withdraw your army! Let the thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of Azerbaijanis return to their lands. They are also our brothers too. Why are you also not approaching this situation in a constructive manner ? Let this be your contributions to the peace. Who seized whose lands, who drove whom away and who committed genocide, The events that occurred in Nagorno Karabakh clearly demonstrate.

100 comments on “Armenian Genocide – Erdogan Responds Armenian Minister (Eng. Subs) Armenia Lies on Armenian Genocide

  1. Все знают что Карабах (Арцах) Азербайджану отдали советские власти а Армяни его отвоевали Карабах был нашим тереторием Армении до появления Азербайджанцев на земле до их истории существования и мы как любая страна защищаем нашы земли от бесчестного врага который убивает детей и стариков таких народов среди нас не должно быть которые ночью бомбят школу изучите историю с двух сторон когда поймете тогда и спорте на эту тему

  2. Fucking stupid world. Turkish Republic was found on 1923. Howcould Tr be responsible of 1915 events. That time ottomans were on the rule.

  3. This guy is hilarious. He is the same guy who makes it illegal too mention the words Armenian Genocide in his country. He is the same guy who chased out of his country a Nobel prize winning author Ohran Pamuk because Pamuk is an educated Turk and tried educating others of their countries history. Turkey has had 100 years to purge their "archives" of any proof of genocide. Of course he's is willing to open the documents up at this time. Armenians were trying to save their lives in 1915 do you think trying to prove what was their reality was important to them at that time? As far as Akhtammar restoration goes, first, Armenians were not allowed to put a cross on the church. Second Armenians were not allowed to regular hold church services at the church. Thirdly, this church was restored to bring tourism to that remote part of turkey. That has been confirmed by the governor of that region of turkey. Look at current events. Look what side of history turkey is on today. Turkey helps ISIS. Erdgoan's son is proven to be doing business with Isis. People, turkey is on the wrong side of humanity past and present.

  4. Well said. Talk is cheap. Armenians and their supporters should bring proof forward but hold the forgeries because they won't fly at this hi-tech day and age. We have over a million original documents in archives. Ottomans were good record keepers. You can't run an empire without bureaucracy and bureaucrats love to log everything on. Bring on yours side by side ours.

  5. if I were erdogan I would be more aggressive towards my enemies and rule with justice

    erdogan is very soft towards his enemies

  6. Hiding behind the Kurdish identity 1.5 million armenian . I know because pkk killed kurdish people . Im from Turkey but ım armenian . Armenians kılled my grandfather

  7. It seems to me that blaming the victim of what you are guilty of is how islam works…
    That's exactly what they do with Israel, that is what they do with Armenians that's what they do with women etc etc etc .

  8. As you can see WE DID NOT DO ANY GENOCIDE FUCKERS!!!! I dont like erdogan much but he is right about this topic!!

  9. you are big lier erdogan if you want something from armenian come i kill youre head big lier i show you video i have photo my grandmother and she tell me everything ok ya sharmoutaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa erdogan

  10. So called armenian genocide. Dr Edward j. Erickson, Prof Justin McCarthy, Prof. Michael M. Gunther,Prof Donald Bloxham, even Prof Richard Hovannasian clearly explains that there is NO genocide. And finally Turkish government offers armenian diaspora $20m open up armenian archive in u.s and they said we dont have money. Armenian genocide is the biggest lie and political propaganda. I think its an easy way to collect money…

  11. Hard Proof has been provided by the Armenians + other sources and Parliaments around the World have recognized the genocide based on hard proof not Erdogay words or shallow evidence . Erdog believes that all the parliamentaries who have voted on the matter around the World after years of assessements and debates are stupid or superficial like him.

  12. Barking its not telling the true… We should not proof the GENOCIDE… The fact is the Ottoman Turkey was the author of the Genocide of Armneians Assyrians Greeks… and you WILL BE PUNISHED FOR IT…

  13. Armenia and Russia should release their archives .Then we will see the facts.Bring us here evidences. Speak the truth. Sneaky Armenians.

  14. Dear Turks your president speaking about archivesHow can we create a commission to attract historians and so dalle you tell yours we will show and do not agree with one anotherThis is meaningless becauseTurkish historians of archaeologists is presented by your president. He manages them. He politicize the history he dont let turkish people to illustrate the truth about events SO
    If you want see our archives then please i invite all the Turks, Come and see the documents and archives And do your own investigation

  15. Mr. Erdogen you are just a Clown in a circus,what about all the Genocide Ottoman Empire committed on Greeks, Arabs ,Assyrians, kurds ,Romanians, Bulgarians, Armenians, and all other Christians.. until now you committing a Genocide among yourselves in Turkey killing your own people,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

  16. It would be nice if the Armenians would recognize the genocide committed against the Azerbaijani Turks committed not so long ago. It is sad how you always seem to portray yourselves as innocents while Armenians thought that they could defeat the Turks together with the Russians. Ask Turks and Kurds from eastern Turkey and they will tell you how their ancestors were murdered by your people. The punishment for treason during war was death. You cannot commit treason and claim to be innocent.
    By casting aside the armed revolts which constituted treason, by not mentioning the deaths that you caused, by not mentioning the crimes committed by your own commanders, by ignoring the effects of contagious diseases and famine in war conditions you try to look as victims. Relocation of populations suspected of disloyalty was a customary war measure both at the time of World War I and through at least World War II. The mass wartime relocation of Ottoman Armenians from the Eastern front was no pretext for genocide.
    Unfortunately many lives were lost on both sides. It is important that we learn from it and stop spreading hate and learn to respect each other.

  17. From the past and present history and with turkey giving support to isis and other freedom fighters (terrorist) it looks like turkey is the aggressor

  18. I do not support the idea of Armenian Genocide 100% however Erdogan Lies when they say they are tolerant toward Christian and preserve churches nothing can be more far from the facts.Turkish destroy and not even allow repair of Christian Churches with out special approval from Turkish Government .

  19. I'm pretty shocked by the opinion of so many people here. Before I'm going into mine, I'd like to say I want a civilised discussion instead of the whole agressive or threatening discussions I see here. I'm a Belgian history student and have a course on the modern Islamic world at the moment (1600-present, but it mostly focusses on the twentieth century). Almost all scholars agree on the fact that The Ottoman Empire did commit a genocide. This was not with the intention of purifacation or eradication of Armenians or Christians, but because they, reasonably, feared that Armenians would side with Russia and would cause them to lose the war. They forced them to move towards Syria, but the non-organised and violent way in which they had to cross even desert, caused more than a million (according to the International Association of Genocide Scholars) deaths, perhaps not all Armenians, but all people from the border region that were forced to evacuate. It wasn't meant to eradicate the Armenians and wether or not it was systematic killing is a topic of discussion in the scholarly world. That put aside, over a million people found death because of their ethnicity, so it is called a genocide by almost all scholars (however the US avoids the word genocide due to diplomatic relations with Turkey). Now, I'm curious after what exactly you believed happened there and what you base this on. I don't care wether you call it a genocide, but I'm wondering wether you believe different FACTS to have happened or not. Friendly discussion only please, I will ignore all rage. Sorry about the long post :p

  20. bizm medentimizde soykirim yok diyor ERDOGAN !!!!
    soykirimin ne demek oldugunu bilmiyorsun da ondan !!!
    ANLATAYIM. da anla ???
    1 -bir mileti yasadigi bolgeden zorla surgun etmek !!!

    2- coluk cocuk demeden katletmek !!!

    3- malarina el koymak !!!

    4- 3000 sene o topraklarda yasiyan bir milletin varligini yok etmek !!!

    5-bunu bildigin halde bu.insan disi SOYKIRIMINI inkar etmek.!!!!
    uluslar arasi bir suctur !!!

    KAHTILLER oldurdugunde tek ve en dogru belge yaptigini kabul etmesidir….
    yok inkar etmek istiyorsan ismin hep SOYKIRIMICI KAHTILLER OLARAK KALACAK bunu da boyle bilesin. ..

    er ve ya gec bunun bedelini odiyceksiniz SULTAN ERDOGAN !!
    yasiyan her ermeni bir belgedir onu da anla !!!

  21. i know alot of proofs
    1-there was a land called giligia
    2-why there is arminian people around the world
    1-why every arminian have his oun city
    like i am aintab
    who is turk
    turk dont have language
    turk came from diffrent kinds of people ataturk….
    i want answers for my quastions
    why azeri attacking artsakh
    if artsakh was to azeri why there is all arminiens in it why
    erdoghan is sayimg this bcz he want to be one of europe countries why there is pic of the genocide bones foun underground
    why france italy russia libanon syria iran have accespted the jenocide china germany spain…….

  22. Armenians will never stop until Justice is served. Time is on the Armenian side as more and more countries recognize the Armenian Genocide. You cannot run away Turkey. It is time to pay for your crimes.

  23. The Turks were at war with the Russians and the Armenians took the side of the Russians so the Turks showed the Armenians the road to Russia.
    The Armenians appeared to not be very well prepared for the journey and perished on route.
    Genocide is in my view what the Americans did to the Indians.
    So happy and proud to be Turkish because we worship fairness.

  24. The Greek genocide, part of which is known as the Pontic genocide, was the systematic genocide of the Christian Ottoman Greek population from its historic homeland in Anatolia during World War I and its aftermath (1914–22).[1] It was instigated by the government of the Ottoman Empire and the Turkish national movement against the indigenous Greek population of the Empire and it included massacres, forced deportations involving death marches, summary expulsions, arbitrary execution, and the destruction of Christian Orthodox cultural, historical, and religious monuments.[2] According to various sources, several hundred thousand Ottoman Greeks died during this period.[3] Most of the refugees and survivors fled to Greece (amounting to over a quarter of the prior population of Greece).[4] Some, especially those in Eastern provinces, took refuge in the neighbouring Russian Empire.

    Thus by the end of the 1919–22 Greco-Turkish War, most of the Greeks of Asia Minor had either fled or had been killed.[5] Those remaining were transferred to Greece under the terms of the later 1923 population exchange between Greece and Turkey, which formalized the exodus and barred the return of the refugees. Other ethnic groups were similarly attacked by the Ottoman Empire during this period, including Assyrians and Armenians, and some scholars and organizations have recognized these events as part of the same genocidal policy.[6][7][8][9][10]

    The Allies of World War I condemned the Ottoman government-sponsored massacres as crimes against humanity. More recently, the International Association of Genocide Scholars passed a resolution in 2007 recognising the Ottoman campaign against Christian minorities of the Empire, including the Greeks, as genocide.[7] Some other organisations have also passed resolutions recognising the campaign as a genocide, as have the parliaments of Greece, Cyprus, Sweden,[11][12] Armenia,[13] the Netherlands,[14][15] and Austria.

  25. Hamidian massacres, 1894–1896
    Main article: Hamidian massacres

    Corpses of massacred Armenians in Erzurum in 1895
    Since 1876, the Ottoman state had been led by Sultan Abdul Hamid II. Immediately after the Treaty of Berlin was signed, Abdul Hamid attempted to forestall implementation of its reform provisions by asserting that Armenians did not make up a majority in the provinces and that their reports of abuses were largely exaggerated or false. In 1890, Abdul Hamid created a paramilitary outfit known as the Hamidiye which was mostly made up of Kurdish irregulars who were tasked to "deal with the Armenians as they wished".[35]:40 As Ottoman officials intentionally provoked rebellions (often as a result of over-taxation) in Armenian populated towns, such as in Sasun in 1894 and Zeitun in 1895–1896, these regiments were increasingly used to deal with the Armenians by way of oppression and massacre. In some instances Armenians successfully fought off the regiments and in 1895 brought the excesses to the attention of the Great Powers, who subsequently condemned the Porte.[37]:40–42

    In October 1895, the Powers forced Abdul Hamid to sign a new reform package designed to curtail the powers of the Hamidiye, but, like the Berlin Treaty, it was never implemented. On 1 October 1895, 2,000 Armenians assembled in Constantinople to petition for the implementation of the reforms, but Ottoman police units converged on the rally and violently broke it up.[35]:57–58 Soon, massacres of Armenians broke out in Constantinople and then engulfed the rest of the Armenian-populated provinces of Bitlis, Diyarbekir, Erzurum, Harput, Sivas, Trabzon, and Van. Estimates differ on how many Armenians were killed, but European documentation of the pogroms, which became known as the Hamidian massacres, placed the figures at between 100,000 and 300,000.[42][43]

    Although Hamid was never directly implicated in ordering the massacres, it is believed that they had his tacit approval.[37]:42 Frustrated with European indifference to the massacres, a group of members of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation seized the European-managed Ottoman Bank on 26 August 1896. This incident brought further sympathy for Armenians in Europe and was lauded by the European and American press, which vilified Hamid and painted him as the "great assassin", "bloody Sultan", and "Abdul the Damned".[35]:35, 115 While the Great Powers vowed to take action and enforce new reforms, these never came to fruition due to conflicting political and economic interests.

  26. some armenıan doggy barking hear yea ı know its hard to listening the truth actually ı dont lıke erdogan but he definitely right ,n this subject

  27. How should Armenia open its archieve when armenia was founded after the genocide and before was under ottoman controll what kind of bullshit is this psychopath talking about ?. Germany has documents and they recognized it as an genocide as well as 25 other countries.

  28. MY ANCESTORS WERE MURDERED AND SLAUGHTERED AND AFTER THE GENOCIDE HAPPENED THE TURKS BASICALLY DESTROYED ALL OF THE RECORDS OF GENOCIDE!!!!

  29. Ottoman Armenies supported and provocated by UK,France and Germany for rebellion and divide Ottoman territory at the end of 19 th century and during 1th World War ..They couldn't be successful .Provocated rebel gangs killed savagely and cruely so many innocent Turks.And Turks bringed the account of this betrayals for Armeny gangs….
    Which genogide?..Provocated opportunist gangs found self trouble who looked for. Meanwhile many innocent people attracted the punishments from each sides too.
    Our sadnes is indescribable for our innocent Muslim people who killed by treacherous gangs.But we are very sad for innocent Armenies too that killed by Armeny gangs partially.
    We never forget our friends and anemies .Who gives hand us for friendship and peace finds,who is anemy finds hostility too.

  30. this fool just said that Palestinians who were clashing with idf and were killed is genocide…this fucking muslim turk should know, they killed over 1.5 million Armenians, he knows what genocide is because his people committed it.

  31. It did happen your barbarian turks killed my great grandparents your a fucken peech orospou lots of turks know it happened everybody is scared to talk or to admit I'm

  32. That filthy erdogan has no shame in his corrupted body. After 1.5 million Armenians olderly children and woman have disappeared from their thousands of year old historical land, murdered and slaughtered he has the gutts to open his lying dirty mouth?

  33. Theere ia not genocide.If turkey made genocide all armenian would have died.Today There is an armenia it means there is not genocide this is a compulsory relocation and killing (maybe to get revenge some tukish men killed but this is not goverment policy) in order to self defence from evil ermenian who in side of russia an who killed and raped turkish woman and child

  34. I have respect for the person that upload this especially with the name Yerevan Armenia. Evrey story has 2 sides.

  35. Armenia is country of piece and not turkey sorry.. i like turkey but turkish peoples are rasist.. we can not say to turkish peoples 'we are from armenia, because he kills me🙄

  36. У армений не хвотает духа чтоб открыт архивы, вот почему вы можете только трепат языком

  37. Very very very very very bad. Even Greek and the earliest christians Assyrian or Syriac christians were brutally subjected to genocide.

    Germans are honest enough to acknowledge it and speak the truth and be sorry for it although the absolute dictator Adolf Hitler was an enemy to his own people and kept their citizens under strict surveillance by spying upon them. Germans have dedicated a museum and the future world and future German children knows it.We all have learnt Jewish Holocaust in school world wide and Ann Frank diary is a book recommended to everyone to study and present in every library of the world even in Christian schools and every christians leaders recommend to read it,as I have read in my Christian school when told by my Christian leaders and was told to criticize and denounce it.Germans tried to renounce their sins brought upon by the Adolf Hitler who was baptized as a Christian as a child but was always an atheist, hold blasphemous ideas and thinking about Jesus and Bible, never attended church and his society rejected the mad- man as "anti- Christian" "atheist and irreligious" and is shamed in every christian families worldwide ( my parents taught me to shame him as a kid) and used false propaganda about his religion to come to power which is utterly rejected by his community. Stupid man use to sell stupid theories of " Jesus an Aryan" to brainwash his generation and used Christianity as a tool to come to power and after coming to power he became" anti- church and anti- Christian and anti- Vatican" and even persecuted a Christian denomination " Jehovah witness".
    Our Christian forefathers and leaders have educated us even about the fact that the greatest seer of all times Nostradamus predicted " someone will come in history represented as red swastika the biggest anti- Christ who will use christ ianity and Jesus falsefully for the evil deeds of Satan and make the pages of history red" and that "psycho, stupid, comical character, brainless, liar, weird, unsocial, mass- murderer, the biggest sinner of all times hands red with the blood of innocent people and sleep disturbed with echoes of innocent crying and tormented by the ghosts of the innocent souls who can't rest in peace in heaven" was "Adolf Hitler represented by " Red Swastika" even so, Bible predicted that " There were also false prophets among the people just as there will be false teachers among you. Peter 2:1.

    Every genocide or organized killing of innocent children, woman and man should be acknowledged as it serve as a checkpoint for future genocides in our generation so that we don't be a part of the sins of the supporters of murder of innocent people as our hands are not red with sins of the blood of innocent people. The moral conscience, ethics and value of our generation is pure.

  38. Armenians talking about events 9f 1915? Turkey is created in 1923 enver pasha run even they did why they blame Turkey? Enver pasha expel sultan and he lost neither ottomans or Turks did this so why they crying for genocide?

  39. Though I'm no fan of Erdogan by any means, his talk in this video to the armenians was perfect!! It's June of 2019 and the armenians STILL have no response to Turkey in terms of opening up their archives or getting out of the ILLEGALLY occupied NK region of Azerbaijan! The armenians know full well that they can't face the Turks in any open public forum with FULL media coverage because if they did the Turks would tear them apart by exposing them in front of the whole world for the LIARS and DECEIVERS that they truly are!

  40. Ananızı sikim ermeniler Karabağı terk edin yoksa mezarınız olucak orası siz Safeviyye evlatırnı daha tanımıyorsunuz ananı sikerler valla Azerbaycan 🇹🇷🐺❤️🇦🇿🇦🇿

  41. Mr. Erdogan I am not surprised for your comments, you have to have a heart like a lion and courage like a tiger to say anything against your present and past Ottoman governments. And if you had the courage you were not standing there talking about eligibility of what Armenians claim.

  42. fuck armenians they think they belong to anatolia , with all these fake churches and chapels made by british and french masonics no 100 years ago , armenians are the people of caucasus not anatolia , we anatolians are the majority and we are natives dna doesnt lie , we are muslims , the handful christians are cacuasus missionaries who settled in ottoman empire .

  43. Here are a few things from Armenian barbaric actions that the armenians DO NOT want anyone to know…:

    Armenian Dashnag officer, Aslem Varaam wrote the following in his report: "I exterminated the Turkish population in Bashar-Gechar without making any exceptions. One some times feels the bullets shouldn't be wasted. So, the most effective way against these dogs is to collect the people who have survived the clashes and dump them in deep holes and crush them under heavy rocks pressed from above, not to let them inhabit this world any longer. So I did accordingly. I collected all the women, men and children and extinguished their lives in the deep holes I dumped them into, crushing them with rocks." [A.Lalayan, Revolutsionniy Vostok (Revolutionary East) No: 2-3, p.92 vd, Moscow, 1936; Istoricheskie Zapisky No 2, p.101, 1928].

    Armenian T. Haçikoğlyan told that the Armenian Dashnaks eradicated thousands of Turks with their bloody hands (T. Haçikoglyan, 10 Let Armyanskoy Sttrelkovoy Divizii,p4-6. İzdatelstvo Polit. Uprav. KKA, Tiflis, 1930).

    ‘In Van, Çarikser Village, a child was bayoneted and was cooked on fire as if he were a lamb by the Armenians. In Van, Ahtucu Village, the six-month old baby of a woman Zeliha, was thrown into the oven (tandir) by the Armenians while she was baking bread. Then the woman was ordered to eat her baby! When she rejected, her right leg was forced into the oven and burned’ [Telegram of Van Gendarme Troop Commander Ali Vasif (May 11 1916)].

  44. so if our ancestors killed each other does that means we have to hate and kill each other too ? we and you aren’t the same people as the ones before us . they are dead . let them rest in peace. forget and forgive the past .

  45. What Armenian rebellious gangs did was much closer to a genocide. Because they acted in order to decrease Turkish(Muslim) population in cities that they wanted. There were Turks living in Yerevan and surrounding area before WW1, hundreds of thousands. They forced them to migrate or they killed these Turks to be able to establish a country in Yerevan. Armenians must explain this before blaming others.

    First Armenian president is personally telling that Armenians did wrong things and Turks were right. This document was found in Moscow and suddenly forbidden by Armenians. Why? Because Armenian Lobby cannot accept any opposing view. That's why!..

    Stop your genocide lies and be sorry for misleading the history!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *